The Could 2 episode of 48 Hours explores the disappearance of Mary Day, who went lacking in 1981 in Seaside, California. Her dad and mom didn’t report her disappearance and Seaside police didn’t even know in regards to the case till 2002. As an grownup, Mary’s sister Sherrie filed a lacking individuals report in 1994, launching the investigation.
The case explores the life and disappearance of the younger lady and the following investigation in 2002. Police have been certain they’d a murder on their palms they usually have been closing in on their predominant suspect, Mary’s stepfather William Houle. Every part modified when the police in Phoenix, Arizona, discovered who they believed was the true Mary Day, alive and nicely.
Nevertheless, detectives and Mary’s personal sisters had rising doubts in regards to the identification of this lady, known as “Phoenix Mary.” Was she actually their long-lost sister, or an imposter making an attempt to say an inheritance many years later? Right here’s what it’s good to know:
Mary Day Went Lacking in 1981 & There Was No Hint of Her for Many years
One evening in 1981, 13-year-old Mary Day went lacking from her household house in Seaside, California. The evening earlier than, she had gotten into an argument together with her stepfather, William Houle, who was stationed on the Military base at Fort Ord. Mary’s stepfather and her mom, Charlotte, instructed the household that Mary had run away and to not ask questions.
Mary’s sister Sherrie Calgaro, who was three years youthful than Mary, lastly instructed authorities about her sister’s disappearance when she grew up. A lacking individuals report was opened in 1994 and detectives in Seaside obtained the case in 2002. Detectives struggled to seek out any info on Mary: there was no document of college enrollment, IDs, paychecks, even arrest data.
Seaside Police detectives have been satisfied that Mary was murdered by her stepfather. Cadaver canines signaled a spot within the yard of the home the place Mary disappeared, and a lady’s shoe was discovered buried in the identical place. William Houle instructed police throughout an interview that they’d a battle the evening she disappeared. He mentioned he didn’t kill her, however a “demon” inside him may have carried out it. Charlotte, Mary’s mom, was additionally behaving unusually. She was uncooperative with the investigation and had no want for her daughter to be discovered, saying, “If she’s useless, she’s useless.”
‘Phoenix Mary’ Was Present in Arizona 22 Years After Mary’s Disappearance, However Doubts About Her Id Grew
Earlier than the police have been in a position to file expenses in opposition to William and Charlotte, and only a few months after they interviewed the 2, the case took a weird flip. The police in Phoenix, Arizona, pulled over a lady throughout a site visitors cease. Her ID revealed her to be Mary Day, and it was issued simply after William and Charlotte have been questioned by police.
Detectives have been stumped since they have been satisfied they’d a murder on their palms. A DNA take a look at revealed that the lady now generally known as “Phoenix Mary” was, in actual fact, Charlotte’s daughter. Regardless of the DNA outcomes, thought, detectives have been nonetheless uncertain about her true identification. She couldn’t bear in mind key details about Mary’s childhood, she had a powerful Southern accent and there have been quite a lot of gaps within the timeline.
Mary’s sisters Sherrie and Kathy additionally had doubts about Phoenix Mary. Kathy mentioned that Mary couldn’t bear in mind something about their father’s inheritance, which they’d regularly mentioned as children. Sherrie additionally seen that Mary had magazines within the title of Monica Devereaux.
A few of the detectives in Seaside nonetheless query the result of the now-closed case. Retired murder detective Mark Clark was satisfied there was a homicide and Phoenix Mary was an imposter. After a picture surfaced of Mary as a younger baby with a household dated after her disappearance, Clark second-guessed his investigation, however he nonetheless contends there could also be some reality to the imposter principle. Different detectives marvel why the cadaver canines alerted within the yard if Mary wasn’t buried there in any case. The 48 Hours episode “What Ever Occurred to Mary Day?” is ready to shed some mild on the story.
READ NEXT: Chad Daybell’s Late Spouse Tammy: Demise Particulars & Replace